Understanding the NCAA Concussion Protocol: Complete Concussions’ Review
Note: This blog was generated with the assistance of AI and meticulously reviewed, edited, and updated by Dr. Mark Heisig to ensure accuracy, relevance, and a human touch. Introduction As…
Buffalo Bills Benford Concussion: A Case for Revisiting NFL Concussion Protocol
Two concussions. Seven days. Christian Benford’s tumultuous week between January 19 and January 26, 2025, reveals glaring cracks in the NFL’s concussion management, sparking debates on the league’s handling of…
Concussions are one of the most commonly misunderstood injuries in sports and daily life. Diagnosing a concussion is not as simple as performing a single test or scan; it requires…
When it comes to concussions, one of the most common questions is: Is it safe to sleep? For decades, myths surrounded the relationship between sleep and concussions, leaving patients and…
Disclaimer: This blog was AI-generated and human-reviewed by Dr. Mark Heisig to ensure accuracy and alignment with evidence-based concussion management practices.
On a night that had the NFL world buzzing, Jacksonville Jaguars quarterback Trevor Lawrence took a brutal hit that left him shaken and ultimately removed from play. The play in question—a late hit with clear helmet-to-helmet contact—was widely criticized as unnecessary and avoidable. While Lawrence’s immediate removal from the game was a win for player safety, the incident highlights both the importance of proper concussion protocols and areas where the NFL still has room to improve.
#TrevorLawrence Will be ruled out due to posturing Obvious visual signs of concussion Hit was late but not to head Head hits turf 2nd documented concussion pic.twitter.com/dmgmQeyDvR
— David J. Chao – ProFootballDoc (@ProFootballDoc) December 1, 2024
Notably, the conversation quickly shifted toLawrence’s shoulder injury and upcoming surgery, which will officially end his season. However, we can’t let the visible severity of a physical injury overshadow the potential long-term impact of a concussion.
Here’s a look at what the NFL Concussion Protocol will involve for Lawrence, why proper management is key, and why concussions need to stay in focus—no matter what other injuries grab the headlines.
The NFL Concussion Protocol: What Happens Next?
The NFL Concussion Protocol is a well-defined process to ensure player safety and gradual recovery. Here’s what Trevor Lawrence’s path will look like:
1. Immediate Removal & Initial Assessment
After the hit, independent medical spotters and team physicians promptly assessed Lawrence for visible signs of concussion, including confusion, balance issues, or tonic posturing—a rigid, unnatural body position indicating brain trauma.
2. Locker Room Evaluation
Once removed from play, Lawrence would have undergone a thorough locker room exam, including neurological assessments, balance tests, and cognitive evaluations. The goal is to confirm a concussion diagnosis and rule out more severe brain injuries.
3. Gradual Return-to-Play Protocol
If diagnosed with a concussion, Lawrence will now progress through the NFL’s 5-Step Return-to-Play Protocol:
Step 1: Rest and symptom-limited activity (light tasks, no physical exertion).
Step 2: Light aerobic exercise.
Step 3: Sport-specific, non-contact drills.
Step 4: Non-contact practice with increased intensity.
Step 5: Full-contact practice followed by medical clearance.
Each step requires the player to remain symptom-free before progressing. This stepwise approach ensures adequate recovery and reduces the risk of Second Impact Syndrome. This rare but life-threatening condition occurs when a second concussion happens before the first has fully healed.
Shoulder vs. Head: The Danger of Overshadowing Concussions
Lawrence’sshoulder injury is significant. It ends his season and will require months of rehabilitation—a timeline far longer than the 3 weeks typical for concussion recovery. However, while visible injuries like ligament tears demand immediate attention, concussions often present less obvious but equally concerning risks.
Subtle concussion symptoms frequently go unnoticed yet carry long-term implications if ignored. These include:
Slowed reaction time
Memory problems
Difficulty focusing
Emotional changes such as irritability or anxiety
Light and sound sensitivity
By focusing primarily on Lawrence’s shoulder, we risk overlooking the importance of proper concussion care. AsESPN highlights, Lawrence’s ability to return to full health will depend on addressing all injuries—head and body alike—with equal care.
Where the NFL Still Needs to Improve
The NFL deserves credit for swiftly removing Trevor Lawrence from play, but more work must be done. Current protocols still seem to be triggered heavily by visible symptoms like tonic posturing or seizure-like activity. While these signs demand immediate action, more subtle indicators—such as disorientation, slowed reaction times, or visual disturbances—can easily be missed.
Better recognition of subtle concussion signs is essential if the league hopes to build on its recent progress. Continued improvements in sideline assessments and early intervention will make the game safer for all players.
Beyond Gear: Why Management Matters More Than Guardian Caps
The NFL has implementedGuardian Caps—over-helmet padding designed to reduce impact forces during practices. While Guardian Caps can mitigate some external forces, they are not a solution to concussions.
Why? Because concussions occur when the brain moves within the skull due to sudden acceleration or deceleration—something padding alone can’t prevent.
Real player safety comes from proper concussion management:
Early detection of symptoms
Gradual, evidence-based return-to-play protocols
Prioritization of neurological health over gameplay demands
In short, while protective equipment has its role, proper care and management remain the most essential tools for keeping athletes safe.
Conclusion: A Win for Player Safety, With Room for Improvement
Trevor Lawrence’s removal from play after his apparent concussion reflects progress in the NFL’s approach to head injuries. Swift action and adherence to concussion protocols protect athletes in both the short and long term.
However, the league must go further. Recognizing subtle symptoms and prioritizing brain health—even when other injuries dominate headlines—is crucial for player safety.
At Complete Concussions, we advocate for proper diagnosis, evidence-based management, and long-term recovery strategies to keep athletes healthy and performing at their best. When we prioritize player safety with the same intensity as we do gameplay, we all win.
Complete Concussions specializes in collaborative, evidence-based concussion care. Our evidence-based training programs and integrated healthcare technologies empower multidisciplinary teams to implement standardized care for those impacted by concussions.
Our network and patient database enables large-scale research to advance concussion management, and ultimately, the long-term health and well-being of concussion patients and also teach them some concussion care at home.
We analyze leading research to develop best-in-class approaches to concussion care.